Best Merchant Services

Best Merchant Services

Disclosure: This content is reader-supported, which means if you click on some of our links that we may earn a commission.

Merchant services exist to help businesses process credit card payments. You might know them by the name “credit card processors.” 

Regardless of what you call them, it’s important to choose the right merchant service for your specific business if you want to take payments from customers.

I’ve reviewed the top six merchant services available today. These are all proven, popular products with reasonable fees.

They all do things a little differently, however, and serve particular types of businesses better than others.

Keep reading to find the one that’s going to fit with your situation. I’ll take an in-depth look at each of the six best merchant services, and conclude by walking you through the major criteria you need to consider as you evaluate your options.

#1. Stax by Fattmerchant Review — The Best for Accepting Any Type of Payment

Pros:

Allows you to accept any type of payment, including ACHNo markup on direct-cost interchangeDeep analytics and reporting

Cons:

Invoicing features only on higher plansNo transparency in pricing for large business package

Stax by Fattmerchant offers a versatile solution with individual packages for SMBs and businesses processing over $5 million annually.

On either track, you can accept any form of payment your customers and clients prefer. In-person, mobile, ecommerce, and ACH payments are all easily handled by Stax on every pricing plan.

And their packages remove any markup on interchange, so you’re not getting gouged there by unforeseen processing fees.

Small businesses can opt for one of three plans. The Growth plan comes with all the payment processing capability, some reporting dashboards and analytics, and a free terminal or mobile reader for in-person payments.

As you scale up in plans, you unlock really useful features. The mid-tier Pro plan includes the ability to send custom invoices (and include a payment link when you send it), payment information storing, enhanced analytics, and the ability to use the Stax API to customize your ecommerce experience.

The Ultimate plan boosts your reporting, insights, and client management. Get deeper analytics, more capability to handle recurring or scheduled payments, and more. Plus, you’ll get a Stax rep dedicated to your account for any assistance you’ll need.

Businesses that process over $5 million annually get their own bespoke plan. That custom-priced offering soups up all the tools and features that small and midsized businesses get from Stax and adds more integrative capability.

So, no matter your entity size or how many payments you process, Stax delivers a robust solution that can offer you much more than payment processing flexibility. Plus, with its scaling packages and dedicated track for large business, you can grow without outgrowing your merchant services provider.

Get started with Stax by Fattmerchant and request your quote today.

#2. Square Review — The Best for Transparent Pricing/Fees

Pros:

No monthly feeTransparent processingFree card readerGreat added features

Cons:

No ACH payment processingHigher fees than desired

Square is popular for its credit card processing and POS systems, but it offers much more. It hosts features such as the “Card on File” feature, allowing users to store customer card information that works great for repeat customers trying to accumulate loyalty points and rewards of that nature. 

The processor also doesn’t have a monthly fee, and while Square’s features might not be as advanced as some of the other payment processors we’re talking about, for a POS without a monthly fee, you can’t beat the value. 

You can accept payments online and in-person, though the transaction costs vary. For in-person sales, expect to pay 2.6% and $0.10 per transaction. For online transactions, it’ll cost you 2.9% and $0.30 per transaction. There are other instances, such as:

Virtual terminal transactionsCard-on-file transactionsAnd card-not-present transactions

These will cost 3.5% and $0.15 per transaction. 

If you have thousands of transactions every month, you can definitely find something cheaper than square.

But for a small business, the lack of monthly fees and price transparency makes it easier to budget than some of the other merchant services. Learn more.

#3. Payment Depot Review — The Best for Established Businesses

Pros:

No contract processingCompetitive ratesEasy to integrate online

Cons:

Best for high-volume businessApplication process

Payment Depot uses a membership pricing model, which can save established businesses a lot of money.

New businesses that aren’t doing so much volume won’t see the benefit (and may actually wind up with higher charges than they would with other services), but if you are already handling a lot of transactions, Payment Depot can be a good choice.

Unlike other companies, the processing fees with Payment Depot’s membership pricing remain consistent and predictable no matter how much business you do.

Because Payment Depot isn’t of passing off credit card fees to the customer at an increased markup, you can wind up saving a ton of money. The more transactions you process, the more you save with the membership pricing.

Payment Depot accepts all major cards and contactless Apple Pay and Google Pay as well. You get next-day funding and integration with top POS systems as well as ecommerce platforms such as: 

ShopifyRevelQuickBooksPrestaShopBigComemrceWooCommerce

I don’t think this is one of the best merchant services for small businesses because of how they structure their pricing. The transaction fees go down as you pay a higher monthly fee, and they seemingly force you to increase your plan because of strict processing limits. 

Here’s a breakdown of their pricing: 

Basic Plan

Fee: $49Transaction Fee: $0.15Monthly Limit: $25,000

Popular Plan

Fee: $79Transaction Fee: $0.10Monthly Limit: $75,000

Premier

Fee: $99Transaction Fee: $0.07Monthly Limit: $150,000

Unlimited

Fee: $199Transaction Fee: $0.05Monthly Limit: Unlimited 

So, as you can see – if you’re doing high volume, it would make the most sense to upgrade to the most expensive plan for the lowest transaction fees. 

#4. Helcim Review — The Best for Small Business 

Pros:

Limited feesFees based on volumeFree online store software

Cons:

Limited integrations$199 for the card reader

If you’re a small business owner, Helcim might appeal to you. With this service, you’re able to process credit and debit cards online and in person. You can also do some of the following: Set up recurring payments and send invoices.

With a Helcim card reader, you can accept all major cards, including Amex plus Google Pay, Apple Pay, and JCB. 

Helcim does not have any contracts or cancellation fees, and they charge $0 in monthly fees. 

Overall, Helcim is affordable but much more for in-person payments than they are online. Here’s a quick breakdown of their pricing structure, which is based on how much business you do each month: 

Monthly Volume: $0 – $25,000

In-Person: 0.3% + 8 cents (+ interchange)Online: 0.5% + 25 cents (+ interchange)

Monthly Volume: $25,001 – $50,000

In-Person: 0.25% + 7 cents (+ interchange)Online: 0.45% + 20 cents (+ interchange)

Monthly Volume: $50,001 – $100,000

In-Person: 0.2% + 7 cents (+ interchange)Online: 0.4% + 20 cents (+ interchange)

Monthly Volume: $100,001 – $250,000

In-Person: 0.18% + 6 cents (+ interchange)Online: 0.35% + 15 cents (+ interchange) 

Helcim offers nice features for those of you looking to integrate this payment gateway into your online store. You can add a checkout to your site for invoicing and customer registration while also accepting recurring subscriptions. 

#5. Flagship Merchant Services Review — The Best for Great Customer Service

Pros:

Dedicated account managerFree account setupFree card terminal (with fees)

Cons:

Confusing ownershipLittle information regarding price

Flagship Merchant Services cut the tape in 2001 and was acquired by iPayment in 2012. Now, they primarily resell iPayment, so keep that in mind. 

This company was one of the first to offer free account setup without any application or fees and real month-to-month contracts. They operate tens of thousands of merchants, and they have a strong reputation. 

Since they’re not a direct processor, most of their merchant accounts are set up through iPayment. iPayment uses First Data as their processor, and it can get confusing trying to figure out who is processing what through what service.

For retailers, Flagship does offer a free credit card terminal, but you’re responsible for paying account fees and insurance on that terminal to keep it up and running. 

For ecommerce, they offer either Authorize.net for processing and integration of an online cart onto your site. 

One thing that was a little frustrating about Flagship is trying to find information on their rates. If you go to their website, you’ll see that you need to fill out a form to get any info about what they charge. 

I’d like to see more transparency, but you may end up with a more catered package deal with this strategy. 

My favorite feature is that you get a single line of contact with the company when you purchase a gateway; they act as account managers. If you ever have a problem, you contact that specific person, and this isn’t a feature I’ve ever seen with any other merchant service.

#6. Stripe Review — The Best for Online Payment Processing 

Pros:

Extremely customizableReasonable pricingGreat solution for online businesses

Cons:

Complicated setupMay require developers

If your business runs entirely online, Stripe is your best choice. It’s made specifically for ecommerce and internet business, and tons of startups and Fortune 500 companies trust Stripe.

The company offers sophisticated software and APIs that allow online store owners to customize their checkout experience. You can use the pre-built integrations to connect a Stripe checkout right away and then customize it as you go along. 

That’s one of the main reasons why I love Stripe; it’s a payment processor that grows with you and allows you to change it as your business needs change. 

With all of these features and moving parts comes complications. It’s not the easiest to set up, and if you plan on utilizing the many benefits of Stripe, you’ll likely need a developer to handle it for you. 

Stripe offers a “pay as you go” strategy–there’s no monthly fee and transaction fees are transparent across the board. 

Online: 2.9% and $0.30In-Person: 2.7% and $0.05International: Add 1% per transactionACH Direct: 0.8% maxed at $5.00 per transactionACH Credit: $1.00 per transaction

You can use all major credit and debit cards plus ACH, WeChat Pay, Apple Pay, Google Pay, and much more. Expect to wait two business days for deposits or pay a one percent fee to get instant deposits. 

Stripe integrates with WordPress, Magento, Squarespace, 3DCart, Zoho, Big Cartel, and more.

How to Choose The Best Merchant Services For You 

Before we get into the reviews, let’s talk about how to determine what makes a good merchant service.

I’ve broken this down into three major areas:

Processing rates/monthly feesServicesType of merchant services account

Let’s go through each of these criteria, one by one.

Processing Rates/Monthly Fees

It’s all about the money, and credit card processing is not as simple as you think. You have to weigh the pros and cons with each service; otherwise, you can end up paying way more than you planned. 

We need to look at the processing rates first. With every merchant service, you pay a small fee each time a transaction is processed. It’s usually between 1 to 3%.

You’ll also pay monthly fees, which vary depending on the service you choose.

To get a lower processing rate, you usually have to pay a higher monthly fee.

So, if you’re processing a ton of payments, a merchant service with a high monthly fee and low processing rates can be a good option.

On the other side, if you’re not processing a lot of payments, having higher process rates won’t hurt you as much as a high monthly fee would. 

There are also the rates that different credit cards like Visa and Mastercard charge. Merchant services like Toast let you choose between flat-rate and interchange processing rates.

With flat-rate, you pay a fixed amount for processing each month. With interchange, you pay whatever Visa or Mastercard charges plus a small fee to Toast.

Flat-rate processing is a predictable solution that works well for businesses that want to avoid big changes in their rates. That said, interchange pricing is generally more affordable. 

Services 

You want to look at what the payment processor offers in addition to credit card processing. Do they offer free POS systems, hardware, mobile payments, integrations, etc?

Some merchant services even offer consulting, customer loyalty features, and invoicing tools. 

Sometimes the “extra benefits” you get from a merchant service provider can outweigh some of the negatives. 

The Type of Merchant Service Account 

There are two primary types of accounts, one is an aggregator (or middleman), and one is an ISO (or independent sales organization). Let’s compare the two and see why it’s important to understand the difference.

Aggregators 

These are middlemen working in between the business and the bank, offering an easy payment processing solution for businesses. Square is an example of this, and while they make it easier, they usually have higher fees and transaction costs. 

ISOs 

Payment Depot is an example of an ISO, and while they usually have a more strict acceptance policy, they offer lower rates and user-friendly software compared to a direct processor. 

Integration

How well will your current systems integrate with your new merchant service?

Whether your are selling online or in person, the product you choose should complement your current process or even enhance it.

Stripe offers a wide range of integrations for popular ecommerce platforms, which makes it a great choice for online stores. It also integrates with the best email autoresponders like MailChimp and GetResponse.

If you are already using these tools, Stripe integrations will make it easier to get set up and stay organized.

You shouldn’t have to redesign your daily workflow to accommodate a new merchant service, so find one that has the integrations to plug right into your business.

Summary

By this point, you should know which of these merchant services is right for you. They all have their pros and cons, and you should choose according to the type of business you own.

Let’s take a quick look back at my top picks:

Stax by Fattmerchant — Best for taking any type of paymentSquare — Best for transparent pricing/feesPayment Depot — Best for established businessesHelcim — Best for small businessFlagship Merchant Services — Best for great customer serviceStripe — Best for online payment processing

My favorite option for any case is Stax. That platform can handle anything, whether you’re large or small.

If your business is already doing a lot of volume, I recommend exploring Payment Depot.

Square is an overall solid solution for all businesses, but the transaction fees are a bit high, and scalability is lacking. 

I’m also a big fan of Helcim because they allow you to grow with your processor by increasing the monthly payment as your volume needs increase. 

Regardless of which choice you make, keep the important factors in mind and choose carefully, so you don’t regret your decision down the road. 

Source: Kissmetrics